Keeping a Dog versus Keeping a Cat

Ken Anderson

Greeter
Staff member
I grew up on a farm, and we had a couple of dogs. At the time and in that environment, keeping a dog didn't seem like much of a problem, not that I was the one responsible for them. They were fed well, with a mix of packaged dog food and food scraps. There were a couple of dog houses around, but I think they slept in the barn during the winter, usually, because, between a large hay mow full of hay, a cow, and a bunch of horses, the barn was always warm, and it was never entirely closed. Since they got their drinking water from the river on the other side of the pasture, the horses were not locked into the barn, and there was always an open door to the hay mow. The dogs were outside dogs, free to roam, and one of them did a lot of that, while the other was usually around. I don't know for sure because I was a kid, and I wasn't responsible for any of that stuff, but I don't think my Dad took dogs or cats to the vet for anything, yet, other than an ocassional injury, they were pretty healthy until they got old. I know that the principal dog, Wags, who they got the year I was born, lived to be at least seventeen, and he was the one that roamed the most. Dad would call the vet to come by for various things involving the horses, or maybe the cow, and he'd ask him to take a look at any cat or dog that had a need while he was there, but otherwise, my Dad would doctor their injuries.

As an adult, I have never had a dog, and it seems to me that unless I lived on a rural property, such as a farm, dogs would require a lot more maintenance than a cat. Just taking them out to urinate on a tree or pole, or to crap on someone's lawn, would be a large responsibility, it seems, especially now that everyone is expected to pick the crap up off of the grass. Plus, I would assume that they eat a lot more. Then, there are the behavioral issues, such as barking, that a lot of people seem unable to resolve, having lived near people with dogs. I don't know if dogs have more medical issues than cats, so I can't speak on that.

Cats, on the other hand, will survive as long as they have food and water, and the better the food, the fewer the health problems. Of course, in order to have a happy cat, they require much more in the way of attention. Every cat is an individual, and some will need more than others, but if you love cats, that part of it isn't a bother, and if you don't love cats, you shouldn't have one. Anecdotal perhaps, but borne out through several cats now, I have found that if a cat eats good food, fleas are unlikely to be a problem. Once I started paying closer attention to what I was feeding them, my cats have not had fleas, and this has been true even when I let them out.

I have never tried keeping a dog in an apartment or suburban home, but I would guess they are far more of a problem than keeping a cat.
 
As a related aside, what's with people who keep a dog chained up in a corner of their yard? I have known people who have dogs that are always left chained up in a corner of their yard, with access to a doghouse and a chain large enough that they don't have to crap right next to their sleeping quarters. Although they may (or may not) be given adequate food and water, that seems like such a miserable existence, and I can't imagine why anyone would want to have a dog if that's going to be their life. If all they're looking for is something that makes a noise when someone comes into the yard, there are plenty of inexpensive digital alternatives.
 
We have both dogs and cats, and the cats ARE a LOT simpler to take care of than the dogs. We have a very large back yard that is fenced, so the dogs can be out and run around as much as they want, but they also sleep inside at night, and can pretty much choose if they want to inside or outside, depending on the weather.
They don’t bark a lot, but they do bark, and also love to howl at sirens. Just to have a guard animal in the back yard, probably a goose would probably work as well as anything. They eat bugs, and don’t have to come inside if it rains, and they will attack any stranger that comes in the yard.

The cats, on the other hand also go in and out as they please. We have a small window that we leave open just enough for the cats to go through and it opens onto the front porch, so if something scares the cats they all dash up onto the porch and in the window like a streak of lightning,
The cats chase rodents and birds, so we do not have our fruit eaten like we did before, and have not had any rats getting inside the house now either.
The cats do a great job !

I love having a purring cat on my lap, and if it were up to me, they would be allowed to sleep on the bed, but Bobby says no cats on the bed at night, so they can only do that if I am taking a nap, or they sit on my lap when I am in the recliner.
 
Always had dogs,even as a kid. I was allergic to cats. Do not think it was over dramatic but got bit by a big cat at about 9 years old. I did not entice the cat in anyway. I was playing all by myself, guess it got spooked.
So prefer dogs, but are very needy compared to cats.
My main dislike are cats that are allowed to climb anywhere. My SIL cats would climb on table and eat out kids bowls while having breakfast. Do not like that at all.Too much freedom for me.
Anyway there are dog and cat people , and we like dogs the best.:)
 
Always had dogs,even as a kid. I was allergic to cats. Do not think it was over dramatic but got bit by a big cat at about 9 years old. I did not entice the cat in anyway. I was playing all by myself, guess it got spooked.
So prefer dogs, but are very needy compared to cats.
My main dislike are cats that are allowed to climb anywhere. My SIL cats would climb on table and eat out kids bowls while having breakfast. Do not like that at all.Too much freedom for me.
Anyway there are dog and cat people , and we like dogs the best.:)
I enjoy indoor cats as long as they act like dogs and stay on the floor. I have known many very picky clean cat owners with immaculate homes who allow their cats to go from the litter box directly to the kitchen counter or dining room table. Outside cats however, can be good rodent control and also be good pets if you sit outside with them. We had one indoor cat who was delightful and was great buddies with our large dog. They would play with each other inside and outside. When the cat tired of the games however, he would head to the roof of the house for a rest.
 
I liked dogs well enough. I grew up with Wags, who was born the year I was, and died not long before I left home. I also remember the two other dogs I had as a kid, Freckles and Lady, and I still get along with other people's dogs. I've just never had one as an adult. As for cats, some people get irate when someone lets their cat go outdoors, and I fully understand the dangers involved. I don't let Ella out anymore, since she disappeared for four days. During that time, I set up cameras in my backyard to see if there was any sign of her, and found that a fox regularly visited the yard at night. I was convinced she had been killed by a fox, but then she turned up one morning. That winter, a family of fishers took up residence in a dilapidated garage in the vacant house next door. The fishers left that spring and haven't returned, but I haven't let Ella out on her own since. I take her for walks outside regularly and bring her out before bed at night so she can listen to the sounds of the night.

At the same time, a cat's life is enriched by time spent outdoors, chasing wildlife, climbing trees, fighting with passing cats, and basking in the sun. There are dangers, however, and the dangers are even greater if you live in a city. Depending on where you live, the advantages of letting your cat have access to the outdoors can outweigh the dangers, though it won't feel that way if your cat is killed. In other places, your cat is best kept indoors. I don't buy into the idea that all cats should be kept indoors at all times, and many of the people who make that argument have never raised a cat beyond 16 years of age, whereas I have raised four of them into their mid-to-late 20s, who could come and go as they pleased.

Understanding how it hurts to have a cat fall victim to danger, I wouldn't criticize either choice, however.
 
I enjoy indoor cats as long as they act like dogs and stay on the floor
Generally, a cat's mood can be determined by its elevation. When their spirits are high, they will be far off the floor, and when they are feeling down, they will be underneath a piece of furniture. That doesn't mean you need to allow them on the table, but I think it's important to have at least one high, sturdy cat tree that gives them the elevation they seek. When they have more suitable options, they won't be on the furniture as much. When it comes to getting up on the table, Ella doesn't make a habit of it, but when I had four cats, it was easier to clear the table before setting it. Four cats are a bit much, and it would be even more difficult if they were kept indoors all the time. I suggest two. While any one cat might insist that it wants to be an only cat, I think cats benefit from having a feline companion.
 
Last edited:
I'm a dog person. I'm allergic to cat dander and to cleaning litter boxes. Also that "straight from the litter box and onto the kitchen cabinets" makes me cringe. None for me, thanks.

We miss having a little dog in the house but neither of us wants to go through the house training, vet bills, grooming, etc. that goes along with owning a pet.
 
I have had both cats and dogs. I really like them both. I have had big dogs and little dogs. With dogs, there is the never ending cycle of taking them outside in all kinds of weather to do their business. We can’t just open the door to let them out and return. We have leash laws and dogs are not allowed to be outside wandering around without a leash. If they got wet or muddy, I would always have to clean them up before I let them back in. Then there were the walks and exercising that needed to be done with dogs; throw the ball, throw it again. Woof, Woof, Woof, can you hear me? Can you see how happy I am?🎾🐶:D

I have a cat. I am obsessive about keeping my cat and the litter box CLEAN. I will not have a house that stinks or reeks of a dirty litter box. If you did not see the cat trees or cat toys in my house, you would never know I have a cat. My cat gets brushed several times a day to prevent cat hair everywhere and too prevent hairballs. My kitty gets the zoomies a couple times a day running through the house. Mostly he sleeps or sits in one of his trees and looks outside at the birds and squirrels. He is very attached to me. A little too much at times. I love a purring cat.🐱🧶😊

EDIT: My cat's litterbox is in a spare room in the house. If I hear him in the box, which I always do, I'm immediately scooping and removing the waste and removing it from the premises. If litter is kicked out of the box, I'm vacuuming it up with my vac stick. I will not have another pet after this one. It is too much work for me at this age.
 
Last edited:
Yes, there is the cat hair, which is annoying whether you're allergic to it or not, and even worse than going from the litter box to the kitchen cabinets is going from the litter box to the bed. I bought a mat with little rubber points all over the surface, intended to clean the litter off their paws when they were done, but the cats would make a point of jumping over it, I suppose because they didn't like the sensation of walking on it. We keep the litter box downstairs, while the kitchen and bedroom are upstairs, so it doesn't generally make it all the way up there.

With four cats, keeping up with the litter boxes wasn't fun. With one or two, it's not such a chore as long as I make a point of scooping them every day and changing the litter completely at least once a week. Feeding them premium foods also greatly reduces the amount of stuff that comes out as waste in the litter box.
 
I always had dogs and cats growing up on the farm as well. I love them both.

When my last house kitty passed away, that was the last cat for me. That is because my two current dogs don’t do well with cats and where I live, I need big watch dogs as you see in my avatar. All I have to say are the words, Pitbull & Pitbull/cross, and that makes a lot of people scared to death to get out of their car🤠🤠

Their huge backyard is in chain-link fence. I open the sliding glass door and let them out. When they’re ready to come in, one of them barks the other one scratches at the door. The problem with these two is they eat so much and dog food is bloody expensive; even the cheap food is expensive and I won’t feed it.

I should add both these dogs are from animal shelters. I have rescued dogs, horses, and taken in stray cats my entire lifetime. My Pet Sematary is full of a lifetime of bringing them home and giving them a decent burial at their end times. I have lost count of the dogs and cats laid to rest in that Grove of trees. There are five horses on the other side of the Pet fence with one to go, whenever the precious fella tells me he is ready..
 
Generally, a cat's mood can be determined by its elevation. When their spirits are high, they will be far off the floor, and when they are feeling down, they will be underneath a piece of furniture. That doesn't mean you need to put them on the table, but I think it's important to have at least one high, sturdy cat tree that gives them the elevation they seek. When they have more suitable options, they won't be on the furniture as much. When it comes to getting up on the table, Ella doesn't make a habit of it, but when I had four cats, it was easier to clear the table before setting it. Four cats are a bit much, and it would be even more difficult if they were kept indoors all the time. I suggest two. While any one cat might insist that it wants to be an only cat, I think cats benefit from having a feline companion.
A window shelf or cat tree would be fine for me. I just don't want them on eating surfaces or even on furniture. Our daughters in Washington both have cats. Eldest daughter's husband built a "Catio" for their last remaining cat (they once had 4). It is really ingenious. It is a roofed (clear) platform that is fenced in . The platform is about 2' x 4' and is situated outside the downstairs bathroom window that can be easily opened and closed. When the weather is cool, the window is closed, but when it warms up, the window in open and the cat has access to the outdoors where it can eye birds but not eat them.
 
I've looked at catios, and they are great idea. I keep thinking that I could build one rather than buy one, but then I never get around to building one. I'll concede that it is difficult to train a cat to stay off of some things, while other things are okay. I won't say it's impossible, but it is difficult. Cats are not so interested in pleasing someone for its own sake. While a dog is motivated to repeat a good behavior when rewarded by accolades of "That's a good girl!" cats consider that to be a given.
 
I feel as you all do about cats and dogs. I am pretty much a dog person but have loved all my animals.
The ones I have learned the most from are my chickens. They teach me a lot about human societies. Their fights for hierarchy, shunning, joining up... People think they are stupid. They are not. They are a lot like us though.
 
We are down to Izzi&Bizzi, a Maine Coon mix who decided to let us live with her as trained staff is hard to find.
Two steel litter boxes on a room size rug in a Jack and Jill, steel scoopers and SO deals with scooping twice a day. Her pantry is the wall cabinet between sinks. Amazon seems to be the best source of wet food. When her last inmate succumbed to a rapid cancer she quit eating kibble all together and wet by the bite only. ChaCha was a Bengal rejected by her humans as too much to deal with, had a temper, was a bully towards Izzy but she was my 25 pound heat pad. I still do not understand why Izzy mourned her.
Brushing is requested several times a day and that loudly and clearly. Food has to be served at the right time in the correct manner. Otherwise it is one flip with a claw and the plate is turned over. It is like the gamble with three cups:)
Some cats are climbers and jumpers others are ground dwellers. She prefers to be on the ground or in her trees. With free run of the house I see no need for a catio.
 
We are down to Izzi&Bizzi, a Maine Coon mix who decided to let us live with her as trained staff is hard to find.
Two steel litter boxes on a room size rug in a Jack and Jill, steel scoopers and SO deals with scooping twice a day. Her pantry is the wall cabinet between sinks. Amazon seems to be the best source of wet food. When her last inmate succumbed to a rapid cancer she quit eating kibble all together and wet by the bite only. ChaCha was a Bengal rejected by her humans as too much to deal with, had a temper, was a bully towards Izzy but she was my 25 pound heat pad. I still do not understand why Izzy mourned her.
Brushing is requested several times a day and that loudly and clearly. Food has to be served at the right time in the correct manner. Otherwise it is one flip with a claw and the plate is turned over. It is like the gamble with three cups:)
Some cats are climbers and jumpers others are ground dwellers. She prefers to be on the ground or in her trees. With free run of the house I see no need for a catio.
You are a good servant.
 
Back
Top