I grew up on a farm, and we had a couple of dogs. At the time and in that environment, keeping a dog didn't seem like much of a problem, not that I was the one responsible for them. They were fed well, with a mix of packaged dog food and food scraps. There were a couple of dog houses around, but I think they slept in the barn during the winter, usually, because, between a large hay mow full of hay, a cow, and a bunch of horses, the barn was always warm, and it was never entirely closed. Since they got their drinking water from the river on the other side of the pasture, the horses were not locked into the barn, and there was always an open door to the hay mow. The dogs were outside dogs, free to roam, and one of them did a lot of that, while the other was usually around. I don't know for sure because I was a kid, and I wasn't responsible for any of that stuff, but I don't think my Dad took dogs or cats to the vet for anything, yet, other than an ocassional injury, they were pretty healthy until they got old. I know that the principal dog, Wags, who they got the year I was born, lived to be at least seventeen, and he was the one that roamed the most. Dad would call the vet to come by for various things involving the horses, or maybe the cow, and he'd ask him to take a look at any cat or dog that had a need while he was there, but otherwise, my Dad would doctor their injuries.
As an adult, I have never had a dog, and it seems to me that unless I lived on a rural property, such as a farm, dogs would require a lot more maintenance than a cat. Just taking them out to urinate on a tree or pole, or to crap on someone's lawn, would be a large responsibility, it seems, especially now that everyone is expected to pick the crap up off of the grass. Plus, I would assume that they eat a lot more. Then, there are the behavioral issues, such as barking, that a lot of people seem unable to resolve, having lived near people with dogs. I don't know if dogs have more medical issues than cats, so I can't speak on that.
Cats, on the other hand, will survive as long as they have food and water, and the better the food, the fewer the health problems. Of course, in order to have a happy cat, they require much more in the way of attention. Every cat is an individual, and some will need more than others, but if you love cats, that part of it isn't a bother, and if you don't love cats, you shouldn't have one. Anecdotal perhaps, but borne out through several cats now, I have found that if a cat eats good food, fleas are unlikely to be a problem. Once I started paying closer attention to what I was feeding them, my cats have not had fleas, and this has been true even when I let them out.
I have never tried keeping a dog in an apartment or suburban home, but I would guess they are far more of a problem than keeping a cat.
As an adult, I have never had a dog, and it seems to me that unless I lived on a rural property, such as a farm, dogs would require a lot more maintenance than a cat. Just taking them out to urinate on a tree or pole, or to crap on someone's lawn, would be a large responsibility, it seems, especially now that everyone is expected to pick the crap up off of the grass. Plus, I would assume that they eat a lot more. Then, there are the behavioral issues, such as barking, that a lot of people seem unable to resolve, having lived near people with dogs. I don't know if dogs have more medical issues than cats, so I can't speak on that.
Cats, on the other hand, will survive as long as they have food and water, and the better the food, the fewer the health problems. Of course, in order to have a happy cat, they require much more in the way of attention. Every cat is an individual, and some will need more than others, but if you love cats, that part of it isn't a bother, and if you don't love cats, you shouldn't have one. Anecdotal perhaps, but borne out through several cats now, I have found that if a cat eats good food, fleas are unlikely to be a problem. Once I started paying closer attention to what I was feeding them, my cats have not had fleas, and this has been true even when I let them out.
I have never tried keeping a dog in an apartment or suburban home, but I would guess they are far more of a problem than keeping a cat.