If my idea is not acceptable, that is perfectly fine. I respect the way this group is run, and I have no problem letting things continue as they are. I was only offering a suggestion, not trying to impose anything on anyone. We can agree to disagree, and I wish you all the best.
Ideas are encouraged, but I can't say that I know just what your idea is. Anyone over 50 is welcome to join the forum, and pretty much the only place where occasionally unpleasant exchanges take place is in the political section, where people sometimes get the idea that they have to hate anyone they disagree with, or that having a differing opinion is unacceptable. That doesn't occur often, but when it does, someone will usually step away convinced that their opinions aren't welcome here. Opinions are welcome here, but someone doesn't necessarily have to agree with an opinion to welcome it. Either way, no one is obligated to take part in political discussions.
Other than that, the forum will grow if members post about the stuff they are interested in, and try to take an interest in things that they might not have thought of otherwise. More posts help to retain current members and to encourage others to join. I know how to do SEO, as I used to do that for a part of my living, but effective SEO costs money these days if the goal is to grow a website quickly, and many of the new people who will be attracted through an SEO campaign are not the ones who will stick around and make the forum a comfortable place to be.
Whether from the perspective of a forum administrator or an SEO professional, the best long-term plan is organic. Since this is a discussion forum, we need to provide discussions. I don't always have the time, but when I can find it, I often think of things to create threads about, or to become interested in topics that I might not have already been interested in.
I also use a lot of words, for which I am occasionally teased, but words are what search engines index, and when the words are on-topic in a thread with a relevant title and descriptive opening post, the thread is likely to be picked up by a search engine, which means that people searching for that topic might be given that thread in their search engine results pages (SERPs), and this brings in potential new members who already have an interest in at least one of our threads. That's why I like to keep things on-topic without being anal about it. When a thread goes in fifty different directions, the search engines don't know what it's about, so it's basically ignored, and if there are too many of them, the whole domain is ignored.
This doesn't mean that every thread has to be about one topic. We have plenty of threads that were designed to go in a thousand different directions. They won't bring us new visitors through the search engines, but they might help to keep the members who are already here. That's fine, from an SEO perspective, as long as the balance doesn't swing too far in that direction.
We're here more for our members than for the search engines, but the search engines bring us new members, so they shouldn't be ignored.
I have started some threads that have some, but not a whole lot of member interest, such as my thread on Pet Food Reviews, because I can keep it on-topic, for the most part, and because the topic is one that people outside of our forum often search for. On some of the search engines, that thread is already at the top of page two in the SERPs; once it makes it to page one, we'll see new visitors. Whether they join will depend on whether they are 50 years old or older, and whether they see anything else here that they are interested in.
Other threads I have started because they were about topics that I like to talk about, and if I like to talk about something, I tend to assume that others would want to talk about it too, although this admittedly could be evidence of narcissism on my part.
Promoting pages from here on other websites can also help with SEO, as long as they are not spam links, and I would like to discourage posting links to this forum on another forum, particularly another senior forum, because that would be bad form.
It would seem that a good way to recruit new members who want to be here would be for members to invite friends and family, but I'm not too sure about that. I have done that many times over the years, and I am aware of only one friend who actually joined, and he never came back after registering. I can't even get my wife to come here often.
When I agreed to restart the forum after our devastating collapse, I decided I wasn't going to focus much on search engine optimization, although we should try to make sure that forum titles make sense, that the opening post is both on-topic and informative, and that we have a good balance of threads that are on-topic and long enough for a search engine to bother indexing them.