Coconut oil and all types of saturated fats

John Brunner

Greeter
Staff member
I commented elsewhere that I've recently acquired a popcorn addiction. I've been using butter flavored coconut oil and a "movie theater" popcorn salt flavoring. I thought I was doing something healthy because I no longer add a ton of melted butter. Then I read the label on the coconut oil. 12g of saturated fat per TB versus 7g for butter. So off to the internet I went.

There are a couple of debates: (1) how bad for you is sat fat in reality, and (2) what are the health differences between sat fat from animals, from plants and from coconut. (Apparently the sat fat from coconut oil is distinct from the sat fat in other plants.) There are conflicting opinions regarding all sat fats. The animal sat fats by themselves are not good for you, but the foods that contain them provide offsetting benefits. Conversely, plants are an incomplete food. In some circles, coconut oil is presented as some type of miracle product (consumed internally and used topically) while detractors say that all the hype has no basis in science and that all sat fats are bad.

I know a few folks here go down the same rabbit holes I do. Do you have any resources or opinions regarding the consumption of coconut oil? It's sort of the latest thing in cooking because of its high smoke point, but what are the health concerns (if any) regarding the sat fat you get from it?
 
I don't use a lot of coconut oil. I do have some cans of coconut cream I should use up, but I haven't touched them in years. Probably fine though, I just stopped and haven't gone back to it.

I wonder how natural it is though. It's not like my people were eating coconuts for millennia.

However butter and even beef fat have been parts of normal diets for a pretty darned long time. And as far as I can tell the highly promoted seed oils can be far worse for you. So while I don't slather on butter I also no longer work hard draining ground beef and then dumping in "vegetable oils."

I just focus more on moderation in quantities today.

Popcorn? I can't help there. I make mine in a microwave bowl designed for the purpose, dry (no oils), and I don't even add salt. I figure I'd rather splurge on a nie pizza instead. But then again I haven't done that in years either.
 
I always have a jar of coconut oil in my pantry, and I always end up throwing it out since I don't use it. At this stage of my life, I am cooking for flavor and not worrying what is "healthy." After a lifetime of using Crisco (starting with my mother and grandma), I'm still here to tell about it. I use all kinds of oils and a bunch of butter. I don't pay much attention at all to saturated fats.

I wrote in another popcorn discussion that we occasionally have a bag of microwave popcorn. It's easy to make and easy to clean up, and all those chemicals taste good. We don't eat much popcorn anymore because I get too much stuff stuck in my teeth.
 
I don't use a lot of coconut oil. I do have some cans of coconut cream I should use up, but I haven't touched them in years. Probably fine though, I just stopped and haven't gone back to it.

I wonder how natural it is though. It's not like my people were eating coconuts for millennia.

However butter and even beef fat have been parts of normal diets for a pretty darned long time. And as far as I can tell the highly promoted seed oils can be far worse for you. So while I don't slather on butter I also no longer work hard draining ground beef and then dumping in "vegetable oils."

I just focus more on moderation in quantities today.

Popcorn? I can't help there. I make mine in a microwave bowl designed for the purpose, dry (no oils), and I don't even add salt. I figure I'd rather splurge on a nie pizza instead. But then again I haven't done that in years either.
I've always been one of those people who will make a soup or a stew the day before I'm going to eat it so it can sit in the fridge for the fat to solidity...then I peel it off. In spite of that, my cholesterol goes well above 300 without statins.

One of the articles I read talked about how much coconut oil is consumed by Filipinos, "and they're not fat." But to me it's the same as the Mediterranean Diet. I think that adopting their lifestyles and continuing to eat as we do would yield better results than retaining our lifestyles and adopting their diets.

I remembered that I have a paid subscription to Consumer Labs, who does independent research on vitamins, supplements, herb and nutrition products for consumers and healthcare providers. From what I just read, I should probably cut back on the coconut oil. Specific research shows that its sat fat is just as bad as other sat fat, and a medium size serving of popcorn (1/4 cup of kernels) has 18g of coconut oil sat fat (1 1/2 TB). Avacado oil seems to be the recommended high-smoke oil for popcorn.

I have always done mine dry in the microwave as well, but then I add melted butter and salt. I bought a container of nutritional yeast to try on it (supposed to be healthy an add flavor), but once the popcorn comes out of the microwave, I reach for the Morton's and the Land O' Lakes. Until I bought these flavorings, I was only eating popcorn maybe 2-3 times a year, always during the cold weather.

But this topic has larger implications regarding low-smoke-point cooking oils. As you said, seed oils are the devil and are to be avoided. Moderation, huh?
 
I always have a jar of coconut oil in my pantry, and I always end up throwing it out since I don't use it. At this stage of my life, I am cooking for flavor and not worrying what is "healthy." After a lifetime of using Crisco (starting with my mother and grandma), I'm still here to tell about it. I use all kinds of oils and a bunch of butter. I don't pay much attention at all to saturated fats.

I wrote in another popcorn discussion that we occasionally have a bag of microwave popcorn. It's easy to make and easy to clean up, and all those chemicals taste good. We don't eat much popcorn anymore because I get too much stuff stuck in my teeth.

My go-to frying fat has become beef tallow, but unlike popcorn, most of the fat stays in the pan. With popcorn, the fat is a dressing. Beef tallow does make a difference...it is so good. Plus it's the recommended fat for seasoning cast iron (I always semi-season my cast iron after I've used it.) But beef tallow is $1/ounce ($14 for a 14 ounce jar.) I'm still working on my first jar.
 
I think coconut oil was just another fad. I didn't find anything special about it. I don't eat popcorn anymore. Like Beth, I don't like it stuck in my teeth. When we use to eat popcorn, I would use peanut oil, which has a high smoking point.
 
Referencing the sentence about letting the stew sit overnight and removing the fat, and still having high cholesterol. There are several things at play here, as well as several different opinion as about the need for cholesterol.

It is not fat that makes cholesterol specifically.
It is that ANY food that comes from an animal has cholesterol in it. We mammals all make cholesterol, and no plant makes it. You can eat a dozen fatty avocados or drink a quart of coconut oil, and there is no cholesterol in any of that; but there will be some in a glass of powdered skim milk, which has no fat, but does have cholesterol.

Aside form that, our body decides if we need cholesterol, and then it makes it, so most of our cholesterol; comes from ourself making it, and not from what we eat.
Apparently, up until the 1950’s, having a cholesterol level of 300 was considered normal. Then they started making the amount lower and selling statins to lower our cholesterol.

Most cholesterol is made for our brain, because that is what uses it the most, and since we started lowering cholesterol with statins, more and more people are suffering with dementia , and at earlier ages than ever before. I would rather have the higher cholesterol than dementia, but that is just me.

As far as what oils are best, I think that using any kind of a natural oil/fat is fine, whether it is from an avocado or an olive or a cow or other animal. The oils that are bad for us are the processed ones from seeds like cottonseed oil (Crisco, sorry , Beth ) soybean oil, rapeseed oil (canola) and any other ones that need high heat, bleach, and chemicals to make them usable for cooking.

Crisco means “crystallized cottonseed oil”, this is where the name comes from.
Originally, the cottonseed oil was developed for machines when regular machine oil was in short supply during the war, but after that they turned it into “shortening” and “margarine”.
They told us that it was healthy and gave away lots of free cooking books to housewives to get them to use Crisco instead of lard in their recipes.
 
I think coconut oil was just another fad. I didn't find anything special about it. I don't eat popcorn anymore. Like Beth, I don't like it stuck in my teeth. When we use to eat popcorn, I would use peanut oil, which has a high smoking point.

I may go to peanut oil and then just add butter. As I told Jacob, I only ate popcorn a few times each year during the cold months. But when I try something new like this, I overdo it and then move onto something else, never to touch it again...but it really tastes like the movie theater stuff.
 
As @Yvonne Smith posted, our bodies make cholesterol, and statins short-circuit that process by stopping the liver from doing that. The drugs also block other things, like Co Q-10 production and undoubtedly other processes we haven't discovered yet. Cholesterol measurement was very primitive and imprecise prior to the 1970s, and although it could be measured, the data wasn't very good and we relied on cholesterol ester assays as the HDLC , LDLC and other similar assays weren't yet available except perhaps in research. I have thought for years that, although the sclerotic arterial plaque contains cholesterol, atherosclerosis is a reaction to something damaging the arterial walls.

 
Referencing the sentence about letting the stew sit overnight and removing the fat, and still having high cholesterol. There are several things at play here, as well as several different opinion as about the need for cholesterol.

It is not fat that makes cholesterol specifically.
It is that ANY food that comes from an animal has cholesterol in it. We mammals all make cholesterol, and no plant makes it. You can eat a dozen fatty avocados or drink a quart of coconut oil, and there is no cholesterol in any of that; but there will be some in a glass of powdered skim milk, which has no fat, but does have cholesterol.

Aside form that, our body decides if we need cholesterol, and then it makes it, so most of our cholesterol; comes from ourself making it, and not from what we eat.
Apparently, up until the 1950’s, having a cholesterol level of 300 was considered normal. Then they started making the amount lower and selling statins to lower our cholesterol.

Most cholesterol is made for our brain, because that is what uses it the most, and since we started lowering cholesterol with statins, more and more people are suffering with dementia , and at earlier ages than ever before. I would rather have the higher cholesterol than dementia, but that is just me.

As far as what oils are best, I think that using any kind of a natural oil/fat is fine, whether it is from an avocado or an olive or a cow or other animal. The oils that are bad for us are the processed ones from seeds like cottonseed oil (Crisco, sorry , Beth ) soybean oil, rapeseed oil (canola) and any other ones that need high heat, bleach, and chemicals to make them usable for cooking.

Crisco means “crystallized cottonseed oil”, this is where the name comes from.
Originally, the cottonseed oil was developed for machines when regular machine oil was in short supply during the war, but after that they turned it into “shortening” and “margarine”.
They told us that it was healthy and gave away lots of free cooking books to housewives to get them to use Crisco instead of lard in their recipes.
I agree with this, I studied the colesterol subject years ago.And it pretty much said what you posted. and that colestrrol is good for the brain.
 
Back
Top