Before going to bed, Ella "asked" for some food, so I gave her a dish of 5.5 oz. As usual, she ate only about 2 oz and started to leave (she usually eats just a little and then comes back for more later), upon which Tigger, seeing food abandoned (although he had just eaten all of his 5.5 oz), came out to finish off Ella's food, which is what an outdoor cat would commonly do. Seeing that, Ella returned to within a couple of feet of Tigger and hissed at him. He ducked at the sound of the first hiss, but continued to finish off her food.
Tigger spent the night, and I decided to spend the night on the futon with him. He is 100% domesticated and fully friendly, with me at least. He started out sleeping between my legs, then moved up to my chest, lying his head on my face, purring loudly. Sleeping was impossible, but fortunately, he didn't hold that position for too long.
I was awakened at 7 pm by Ella making exaggerated noises in her litter box in the adjacent room. Either she was trying to wake me up, or she was taking her frustrations out on the litter. From there, she came out and stood in the entranceway, staring at Tigger and me. Not wanting her to feel excluded, I invited her in, and she attacked Tigger.
Well, it had all the noise and motion of an attack, but she didn't make contact, kind of like a bluff attack from a bear, perhaps. Tigger looked like he was preparing to defend himself at first, but then he opted to go behind or under the futon. Ella wanted to look for him to continue the quarrel.
Instead, I picked Ella up and sang to her, hoping to transfer some of her anger at Tigger to me, given that she hates it when I sing to her. Then, I began caressing her nose and cheeks, which generally have a calming effect, and they seemed to. She went upstairs, where I found her pouting on the bed.
Once Ella left, Tigger came out and went to the exterior door to signal that he wanted out, the second time he had done that after an unpleasant encounter with Ella, but again, once I opened the door for him, he changed his mind, probably thinking that, while he had a crabby old woman (Ella, not my wife) who didn't think he belonged in the house, there was a large black cat who didn't want him outside. Plus, it's warmer in here, with cat trees, cat beds, and food. He returned to the room with the futon.
Later, I fed Ella near the library door, and fed Tigger in another room. Ella ate her usual small amount, then went upstairs. Tigger cleaned his plate, but did not take Ella's food, so I brought him some more as a reward. If things work out as I think they will, and Tigger remains an inside cat, he will eventually quit feeling like he has to eat everything in sight.
The rest of the day went okay. Ella has remained upstairs, and Tigger is downstairs, while I have been trying to divide my time. Ella doesn't seem angry anymore, but will probably regain some anger when she sees Tigger again.
So, Tigger has been inside for over 24 hours now and no one has gotten hurt.